Shelter Island, NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale Listings

Search Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale with Local Real Estate Experts, The Agency Hamptons.

Browse Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY

Browse the available properties in the Shelter Island below.

For Sale
MLS® 934615

$14,500,000

28 ROXBURY LA, East Hampton, NY 11937
6 Beds 8.5 Baths 5,337 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 934607

$8,500,000

3 Bevan Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
3 Beds 2.5 Baths 1,798 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 934586

$8,500,000

18 Gansett Ln, Amagansett, NY 11930
4 Beds 4 Baths 3,000 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 933803

$1,149,000

21 S FULTON ST #5, Montauk, NY 11954
2 Beds 2.5 Baths 1,400 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 933457

$399,000

95 SPRINGVILLE RD UNIT 17 Unit: Apartment 17, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
1 Bed 1 Bath 620 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 932862

$3,795,000

19 Wolf Way, East Hampton, NY 11937
6 Beds 6.5 Baths 3,400 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 932816

$7,395,000

9 Old Montauk Highway, deep flag lot, Amagansett, NY 11954
5 Beds 4.5 Baths 3,133 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 932773

$3,395,000

56 N Woods, East Hampton, NY 11937
4 Beds 4 Baths 4,000 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 931474

$1,795,000

21 OVERLOOK DR, Southampton, NY 11968
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,700 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 931264

$5,995,000

5 Rogers Court, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
7 Beds 7.5 Baths 6,500 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 930703

$7,500,000

10 Springs Fireplace Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937
6 Beds 8 Baths 3,941 Sq.Ft.
For Sale
MLS® 930569

$3,595,000

3 Wilson Pl, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
5 Beds 3.5 Baths 3,100 Sq.Ft.
View More Homes in The Hamptons

Find Your Dream Shelter Island Home.

Schedule a Showing

Neighborhood Guides

Browse things to do, places to see, and landmarks to explore in Shelter Island, NY and nearby areas.

Montauk

Montauk

Learn More
Amagansett

Amagansett

Learn More
East Hampton

East Hampton

Learn More
View All

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Updates

Read the latest news, tips, and insights for the Shelter Island real estate market.

VIEW ALL

Your Hamptons Dream Home with The Agency

Whether you're looking to buy or sell a luxury property in the Hamptons, The Agency is your trusted partner. With deep local expertise in Bridgehampton, East Hampton, and surrounding areas, we offer personalized service tailored to your unique needs. Our boutique approach, combined with global marketing reach, ensures your property stands out in a competitive market. Let us help you find your ideal home or achieve the best return on your investment. Experience the difference with The Agency Hamptons.
Contact Us

Contact details

The Agency Hamptons

Phone

(631) 899-3224

Email

[email protected]

Address

Bridgehampton Office PO Box 313 2462 Main Street Bridgehampton NY 11932 East Hampton Office PO Box 1886 55 Main Street East Hampton NY 11937

Submit a message

Message sent successfully!