The Hamptons, a series of villages and hamlets on the eastern end of Long Island, is known for its stunning beaches, prestigious gatherings, and celebrity sightings — and also for its exceptional dining scene. From quaint, beachside shacks serving fresh seafood to upscale eateries with Michelin-star ambitions, The Hamptons offers a diverse array of gastronomic delights that cater to every palate. This blog will guide you through some of the best restaurants in The Hamptons that are a must-visit for any food lover.
Montauk
The Crow’s Nest
The Crow’s Nest is a Montauk gem that masterfully blends rustic charm with elevated dining. Situated on the edge of Lake Montauk, this restaurant offers breathtaking sunset views that enhance every meal. The menu focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, with dishes like grilled branzino and the famous heirloom tomato salad stealing the show. The outdoor seating area, complete with cozy fire pits and lush greenery, makes it an ideal spot for a romantic evening or a relaxed dinner with friends.
Harvest on Fort Pond
Located right on Fort Pond in Montauk, Harvest on Fort Pond is known for its hearty portions, Mediterranean-inspired cuisine, and scenic waterfront setting. The restaurant’s commitment to quality shines through in dishes like wood-fired pizzas, house-made pasta, and fresh salads. Each dish is designed for sharing, making it a popular spot for groups and gatherings. Harvest on Fort Pond’s outdoor seating area is a highlight, offering guests beautiful pond views and a serene dining experience.
Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Inlet Seafood Restaurant is celebrated for its stunning views and fresh, locally sourced seafood. Its location overlooks the inlet, letting you breathe the salty air in anticipation of a delicious meal. Owned and operated by six local fishermen, this restaurant serves an impressive range of seafood dishes, including Montauk-caught lobster, sushi, and daily fish specials that highlight the day's catch. The restaurant’s waterfront setting provides guests with breathtaking ocean and Inlet views, making it ideal for lunch and dinner.
Scarpetta Beach
Scarpetta Beach, located within the luxurious Gurney’s Montauk Resort, pairs a refined Italian dining experience with stunning oceanfront views. This elegant restaurant brings Scarpetta’s signature NYC flavors to Montauk, emphasizing fresh seafood and handmade pasta. Guests rave about the creamy polenta with truffled mushrooms and the perfectly executed spaghetti tomato basil. The chic, airy interior complements the coastal setting, while the terrace provides a spectacular backdrop for al fresco dining.
East Hampton
1770 House Restaurant & Inn
1770 House is a hallmark of East Hampton’s dining scene, situated in a historic colonial home. The candlelit dining room exudes warmth and charm, making it a top choice for a romantic evening or special occasion. For a more relaxed vibe, head to the downstairs tavern and order the buttery lobster risotto or perfectly cooked beef tenderloin. Try their signature sticky toffee pudding or enjoy a glass of wine from their extensive list.
Bostwick’s Chowder House
Bostwick’s Chowder House is an East Hampton favorite for casual, no-frills seafood dining. This laid-back eatery serves up some of the best clam chowder on Long Island alongside a menu filled with fresh seafood classics like lobster rolls, fish tacos, and fried clam strips. The outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying a sunny afternoon while savoring the day’s catch.
East Hampton Grill
East Hampton Grill combines upscale dining with a relaxed, approachable vibe, making it a staple of the East Hampton culinary scene. The restaurant is known for its wood-fired rotisserie chicken and the crowd-pleasing “Heavenly Biscuits,” which live up to their name. A meticulously curated wine list and craft cocktails add to the elevated dining experience. The sleek, contemporary interior offers an inviting atmosphere for everything from casual dinners to celebratory meals.
Moby’s
Moby’s brings a chic, modern twist to Mediterranean-inspired dining in East Hampton. Set in a beautifully designed space with coastal decor and lush outdoor seating, this restaurant feels like a luxurious escape. The buzzing atmosphere makes Moby’s a hotspot for dinner with friends or a lively date night. Its impressive cocktail program and curated wine list perfectly complement the flavorful dishes, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience.
The Palm
The Palm in East Hampton brings a classic steakhouse experience to the Hamptons with a touch of elegance and sophistication. Signature dishes include the jumbo Nova Scotia lobster, the classic filet mignon, and delicious side options like creamed spinach and three-cheese potatoes au gratin. The warm, upscale atmosphere at The Palm is perfect for a special occasion or romantic dinner. The restaurant’s longstanding reputation and commitment to quality make it a staple in East Hampton, and it’s easy to find — just down Main St. from the town center.
Wainscott
Highway Restaurant & Bar
Highway Restaurant & Bar in Wainscott is a culinary gem with a relaxed, inviting atmosphere. Known for its seasonal New American menu crafted with locally sourced ingredients, Highway offers an elevated dining experience that caters to a variety of tastes. From the delightful shrimp spaghetti to Thai chicken stir fry and braised short ribs, every plate is a celebration of flavor and top-tier quality. Don’t miss Happy Hour or Peking Duck on Fridays. Whether you’re enjoying a great dinner or gathering with friends, Highway delivers a quintessential Hamptons dining experience.
Sag Harbor
Beacon
Perched on the waterfront with stunning views of Sag Harbor Cove, Beacon uses fresh, seasonal ingredients. Inspired by American and Mediterranean influences, the menu features delectable dishes like grilled octopus with chorizo and fingerling potatoes, pan-seared scallops with butternut squash risotto, and wood-fired pizzas with creative toppings. The spacious outdoor patio, with its breathtaking harbor views, is the perfect place to enjoy a sunset cocktail and soak up the vibrant energy of Sag Harbor.
Bell & Anchor
For a taste of classic New England seafood with a refined twist, Bell & Anchor is a must-visit. This charming restaurant, housed in a historic building, boasts an impressive wine list and handcrafted cocktails, making it a perfect destination for a leisurely lunch or a romantic dinner. The menu features delectable dishes like lobster rolls, clam chowder, pan-roasted local fluke, and grilled swordfish with seasonal vegetables. Bell & Anchor's commitment to quality and sustainability is evident in every dish.
Estia’s Little Kitchen
Estia's Little Kitchen is an excellent option for those seeking a taste of Greece in the heart of Sag Harbor. This charming eatery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a casual lunch or a quiet dinner. The menu features traditional Greek dishes like moussaka, spanakopita, gyros, and souvlaki, all made with love and care. The friendly service and delicious food will transport you to the sun-drenched shores of the Mediterranean.
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
The stylish Lulu Kitchen & Bar offers a modern take on Mediterranean cuisine. The menu features dishes cooked in a wood-burning oven and grill, resulting in bold flavors and unique culinary creations. You'll find compelling options like grilled octopus with romesco sauce, wood-fired pizzas with seasonal toppings, and roasted lamb with couscous and harissa. The spacious outdoor patio and a bustling bar scene make it a popular destination whether you’re in for food or just drinks.
Page
With its elegant ambiance, beautiful interior design, and charming patio, Page is an ideal destination for a special occasion or a romantic dinner. The menu features roasted duck breast with wild rice and huckleberries, pan-seared scallops with cauliflower purée and black truffle, and grilled swordfish with roasted vegetables and salsa verde. The restaurant also boasts an extensive wine list and handcrafted cocktails curated to complement the exquisite cuisine.
Shelter Island
Leon 1909
Leon 1909 brings a European-inspired charm to Shelter Island. This cozy yet elegant restaurant features an array of Mediterranean flavors, from perfectly grilled fish to handmade pasta dishes infused with seasonal produce. The rustic-chic decor, warm wood accents, and inviting ambiance make it a favorite for casual meals and romantic dinners. Leon 1909’s outdoor patio is enchanting, providing a tranquil setting to enjoy a meal under the stars.
The Pridwin
The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages is a historic icon on Shelter Island and home to one of the area’s most celebrated dining venues. Overlooking the picturesque Crescent Beach, the restaurant offers breathtaking views with a menu featuring fresh seafood, prime cuts of meat, and vibrant, seasonal vegetables. The Pridwin’s dining experience seamlessly combines old-world charm with modern culinary innovation, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach is a chic waterfront restaurant that exudes effortless elegance and draws a stylish crowd. Perched on the sandy shores of Shelter Island, this hotspot offers a distinctly European vibe with its airy decor, striped umbrellas, and laid-back yet lively ambiance. As the name suggests, the views here are spectacular, especially during the golden hour when the sun dips into the horizon. Try the tuna tartare, lobster spaghetti, or locally sourced salads.
Vine Street Cafe
Vine Street Cafe is a culinary gem with a welcoming atmosphere that will make you glad you made the trip to Shelter Island. Highlights include their famous duck confit, decadent truffle mac and cheese, and fresh seafood specials showcasing the best local waters. With a thoughtful wine list and decadent desserts, every course is designed to impress. Vine Street Cafe’s dedication to hospitality and attention to detail make it a favorite among locals.
Bridgehampton
Almond
Almond in Bridgehampton offers a relaxed, rustic setting with a French-inspired menu emphasizing locally sourced ingredients. Co-founder and chef Jason Weiner prioritizes personal relationships with local growers, fishermen, artisans, and winemakers. Popular dishes at Almond include steak frites, roasted chicken, and various seafood options, each prepared with a nod to traditional French techniques. As of this writing, the restaurant has a two-course prix fixe on special for $39. Beyond its sumptuous dinners, Almond is a community focal point, hosting regular local artist showcases and karaoke on Saturdays.
Bridgehampton Inn & Restaurant
Bridgehampton Inn & Restaurant infuses the charm of a historic inn with the sophistication of modern dining. The restaurant’s dishes are elegant yet approachable, ranging from fresh seafood options to creative takes on classic American comfort food. The well-curated wine list perfectly complements the menu, making it an ideal choice for a relaxed dinner or special occasion. The Inn’s cozy ambiance, rustic decor, and inviting fireplace add to its reputation as a standout dining destination in the Hamptons.
Elaia Estiatorio
Elaia Estiatorio brings a slice of the Mediterranean to Bridgehampton with its authentic Greek cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its high-quality, fresh ingredients, Elaia offers dishes like grilled octopus, perfectly seasoned lamb chops, and a variety of mezze plates ideal for sharing. The restaurant’s light and airy decor, whitewashed walls, and natural wood accents transport diners to a coastal Greek taverna. Its outdoor patio is particularly enchanting during warmer months, providing a perfect setting for leisurely meals under the sun or stars.
John-Georges at Topping Rose House
Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House is the epitome of refined dining in the Hamptons. Located in a luxurious boutique hotel, the restaurant offers a menu that reflects Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s signature blend of French and American flavors with a modern twist. The dining room exudes understated elegance with its plush seating and artful decor, while the outdoor patio provides a serene setting for alfresco dining. Whether you’re indulging in brunch, lunch, or dinner, Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House delivers a world-class culinary experience in an exquisite setting.
Pierre’s
Pierre’s is a quintessential Hamptons dining spot that pairs a chic and lively ambiance with exceptional French cuisine. Situated on Main Street, the restaurant features a bistro-style menu that includes everything from fresh oysters and escargot to hearty steak frites and delicate soufflés. The bright and airy dining room, with its stylish decor and floor-to-ceiling windows, creates an inviting atmosphere that feels casual and sophisticated. Pierre’s also boasts a charming outdoor seating area, perfect for people-watching while enjoying a glass of wine.
Water Mill
Bistro Ete
Bistro Ete exudes classic French charm with its cozy ambiance and a menu that celebrates the flavors of Provence. This charming bistro, housed in a beautifully restored farmhouse, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a romantic dinner or a leisurely lunch with friends. The menu features traditional French dishes like steak frites, moules marinières, and roasted chicken, all prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant also boasts an impressive wine list featuring French and international selections and handcrafted cocktails.
Calissa Hamptons
Calissa Hamptons transports you to the sun-drenched shores of the Greek Islands with its vibrant atmosphere and authentic Mediterranean cuisine. This stylish restaurant features a menu that celebrates the fresh flavors and vibrant colors of Greece, with dishes like grilled octopus, whole roasted fish, and flavorful salads. The restaurant also hosts live music events, adding to the energetic ambiance. Whether you're seeking a taste of Greece or a vibrant night out, Calissa Hamptons delivers a memorable dining experience.
Suki Zuki
Suki Zuki is a modern Japanese restaurant with a creative selection of sushi rolls, sashimi, and other Japanese specialties, all crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you're a sushi connoisseur or simply seeking a delicious and stylish dining experience, Suki Zuki will impress. The restaurant also boasts an impressive sake list and handcrafted cocktails, perfect for complementing your meal and enjoying a night out.
Southampton
Dopo Argento
For its handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and perfectly cooked meats, Dopo Argento is a standout Italian eatery in Southampton. The menu ranges from classic upscale Italian dishes to more casual fare like BLTs. An impressive wine list complements the meal, with options that pair beautifully with the rich flavors of the cuisine. Whether it’s a casual night out or a special occasion, Dopo Argento is a go-to spot for an authentic Italian experience in the Hamptons.
The Plaza Café
The Plaza Café has been a Southampton staple for decades, celebrated for its impeccable seafood and farm-to-table approach. Dishes like pan-seared scallops, Maine lobster, and wild-caught fish are prepared creatively. The intimate dining room exudes charm, featuring warm tones and a cozy atmosphere, making it ideal for romantic dinners or small gatherings.
Sant Ambroeus
Whether you’re enjoying an espresso in the morning or a full-course dinner in the evening, Sant Ambroeus captures the essence of Italian hospitality with its exceptional food and polished service. The menu combines classic Italian dishes with a refined presentation, including standout options like the Vitello tonnato, homemade pasta, and decadent desserts such as tiramisu and panna cotta. The chic, European-inspired decor, with its marble accents and soft hues, adds to the restaurant's upscale vibe.
Tutto Il Giorno South
Tutto Il Giorno South is a gem in Southampton, blending rustic Italian charm with a contemporary twist. The menu emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients, showcasing creamy burrata, rich ragù pasta, and expertly grilled seafood. The interior is equally inviting, featuring a mix of modern and rustic decor with warm wood tones and an open, airy layout. The restaurant’s outdoor seating area offers a serene setting for enjoying meals under the Hamptons sun.
Hampton Bays
Cowfish
Cowfish is a stylish and popular restaurant that blends the best of land and sea. This contemporary eatery boasts a menu featuring delectable seafood dishes and mouthwatering steaks, ensuring there's something for everyone. With a spacious outdoor patio overlooking the Shinnecock Canal, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a leisurely lunch or a romantic dinner while soaking up the waterfront views and vibrant energy of Hampton Bays.
Edgewater Restaurant
Edgewater Restaurant is a Hampton Bays institution renowned for its breathtaking waterfront location, which yields panoramic views of Shinnecock Bay. Guests love the lobster pasta, risotto, and duck, among other favorite dishes. Their menu features fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, ensuring a delicious and authentic taste of the Hamptons. Edgewater has a unique combination of stateliness and friendliness.
Rumba
Rumba transports you to the vibrant shores of the Caribbean. This colorful restaurant and bar serves jerk chicken, conch fritters, and fresh seafood prepared with Caribbean spices. Rumba's laid-back vibe and waterfront location make it a popular destination for those seeking a taste of island life. With live reggae music and creative cocktails, it’s an unforgettable experience in the heart of Hampton Bays.
Amagansett
Rosie’s Amagansett
It’s easy to find Rosie’s on Main St. in Amagansett. The bright, welcoming interior and laid-back atmosphere make Rosie’s a comfortable choice for any meal. The farm-to-table menu celebrates local produce and changes with the seasons, offering dishes that reflect the flavors of the East End. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner options are available, with standout dishes like avocado toast, vibrant salads, and seasonal entrees that highlight fresh, organic ingredients. Rosie’s is a charming, cozy spot.
Savoring The Hamptons
After exploring some of the best restaurants in The Hamptons, it's clear that this locale is not just about the beaches and the glamour—it's also a haven for food enthusiasts. Whether you're craving fresh seafood by the ocean or sophisticated dishes in a historic setting, The Hamptons offers a rich tapestry of culinary delights. And if you're looking to make this gastronomic paradise your home, don't hesitate to contact The Agency Hamptons. They'll help ensure your real estate journey is as seamless and satisfying as the dining experiences above.
Discover More in The Hamptons with The Agency Hamptons
The Hamptons' culinary scene is a dynamic and evolving landscape, offering everything from casual beachfront eateries to upscale dining rooms. Each restaurant not only serves excellent food but also provides a glimpse into the lifestyle and culture of The Hamptons.
For those captivated by the charm and luxury of The Hamptons and considering making it their home, The Agency Hamptons is your ideal real estate partner. With a profound understanding of the local market and a commitment to exceptional service, The Agency Hamptons can help you find your perfect home in this coveted destination.
